Solar shading · Performance
External shading versus internal blinds: what the research shows
This article is compiled from official statistics, regulations, standards and industry publications; sources are listed at the end.
- g tot, the solar energy transmittance of glazing and shading combined, is the measure of a shading product’s thermal effect, and a lower figure means less heat in the room [1].
- In an Athens house simulation, the cooling demand saved by external venetian blinds rose from 21% with manual operation to 39% with automatic control [2].
- For an office building in Antalya, the most effective fixed external shading lowered cooling energy by 73–78% where the glazing performed poorly and by 37–49% where it performed well [3].
- Fabric colour reverses its effect with position: outside the glass dark grey performs better than white (g tot 0.08 against 0.11), while behind it the ranking flips [4].
An internal blind and an external zip screen can use the same fabric and still perform very differently, because what counts is where solar radiation is intercepted. Outside the glass, most of the heat is stopped before it reaches the window; inside, it has already passed through the glazing and has to be dealt with in the room. European policy now treats this as more than a comfort issue, as the recast Energy Performance of Buildings Directive puts measures against overheating, such as shading and passive cooling, first in line [5]. This article looks at how the difference is quantified, what research figures say and how to use them in a project.
To discuss external shading for your project, contact Ferrini on +90 232 864 22 20 or at info@ferrini.com.
Quantifying the difference with g tot
EN 14501 sets out how blinds and shutters are classified for thermal and visual comfort [1]. Its thermal value, g tot, is not a property of the fabric or of the glass but of the two working together, so a single figure on a datasheet only makes sense alongside the glazing it was calculated for. Placed outside, the same fabric gives a much lower g tot than it does behind the window.
The value also carries regulatory weight. In France, the technical criteria for the 5.5% reduced VAT rate on energy renovation include the g tot of external solar protection [6]. For architects and contractors, the practical conclusion is to ask for a documented g tot when comparing products, and to solve shading outside the glass wherever the facade allows.
Reading the research figures
The Athens and Antalya results are not directly comparable. One models a dwelling, the other an office building, and both are simulations rather than measurements [2, 3]. The Antalya work ran through 1,485 scenarios, and the benefit of fixed external shading was considerably greater where the glazing itself performed poorly [3]. In Athens, the identical blind delivered more under automatic control than under manual use, which suggests that the way a product is operated matters as much as the product [2].
Each figure depends on assumptions about the building, its climate and its use. Read them as an indication of direction and scale rather than as a forecast of what a given project will save.
Automation and control
Control strategies are developing in the same direction. In a 2025 study, the angle of shading slats was predicted in advance using machine learning; energy use on south and west facades fell by more than 30%, and glare was absent in 88–91% of the hours over the year [7]. The value of shading is therefore moving from the hardware towards the control logic that runs it.
Frequently asked questions
Does a dark external screen let more heat into the room than a light one?
No, according to a sector guide based on EN 14501. It finds that a dark colour carries no solar-control penalty when the fabric is outside the glass, whereas in an internal blind the lighter fabric does better [4]. In Ferrini’s production records, anthracite grey reached a 63% share of roller shutters and zip screens in 2023, so the most common choice is also a sound one for solar control.
How far is external shading automated in practice?
In 2025, motors were fitted to 98% of the zip screens Ferrini produced but to 50% of its brise-soleil and external venetian blind family, according to its production records; the latter still includes many manually adjusted and fixed-louvre installations. Motor and control choices therefore belong in the performance specification rather than on the accessories list, since research shows that automatic control can raise savings [2].
Sources
- CEN, EN 14501:2021 Blinds and shutters – Thermal and visual comfort – Performance characteristics and classification (consolidated version EN 14501:2021+A1:2025), March 2021; 2025. https://iteh.es/catalog/standards/cen/8b0257b8-f10b-4994-ae49-2493d6cd12ab/en-14501-2021
- ES-SO (European Solar-Shading Organisation) Technical Committee, Conventional control strategies for shading devices in residential and office premises, March 2025 (industry association publication). https://es-so.com/onewebmedia/news/Control%20Strategies%20for%20shading%20devices.pdf
- Koç, S. G. and Maçka Kalfa, S., The effects of shading devices on office building energy performance in Mediterranean climate regions, Journal of Building Engineering 44, 102653, 2021, DOI 10.1016/j.jobe.2021.102653. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352710221005118
- ES-SO / Solskyddsförbundet, Solar shading for low energy buildings (with EN 14501 classification), 2012 (industry association publication). https://www.solskyddsforbundet.se/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Solar-shading-for-low-energy-buildings.pdf
- European Parliament and Council, Directive (EU) 2024/1275 on the energy performance of buildings (recast), OJ L, 08.05.2024. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202401275
- Légifrance, Arrêté du 4 décembre 2024 (KDV %5,5 enerji renovasyonu teknik kriterleri), published 24 December 2024, accessed 02.10.2026. https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/jorf/id/JORFTEXT000050823106
- Wang, M.; Jia, Z.; Xiang, C., Machine learning-based adaptive control of PV shading for residential energy and visual comfort optimization, 1 September 2025, accessed 02.10.2026. https://researchportal.hkust.edu.hk/en/publications/machine-learning-based-adaptive-control-of-pv-shading-for-residen/

